11/03/2026
“They do not want straight sided sheep…” Lynn Fahrmeier
They do care; they do not want to buy crap lambs, like some people think…” David Fisher
(David Fisher) “…didn’t want to just be a “price taker”
Source: 2026 ALB convention panel discussion
These are sheep producers and sheep industry leaders. It is hard to avoid what they are saying. They are sheep businessmen and businesswomen. They are interested in the reputation of the sheep products produced in the USA. They discussed imports, various markets, sales strategies, sheep improvement, competition from imported lamb…
St. Croix sheep breeders: It is hard to avoid what they are saying. Let’s flesh this out a bit for our breed.
• Are your sheep something that you are proud to sell as associated with your name?
• Do you just have sheep to eat lamb or want to raise a few? Do you get adequate meat from each of your lambs to make it worth the effort and the cost?
• Do you just dump sheep on the market and hope that they sell OK?
• Do you sell as many registered sheep as possible, regardless of quality, to try to break even or just try to not lose too much money?
• Do you have happy repeat customers, especially the commercial customers?
• Are your sheep valuable because of you own them, because of the famous pedigrees or are they really good functioning sheep that yield acceptable carcasses?
The St. Croix Breed started in the 20th century and efforts were made to preserve the new breed by getting as many new flocks established as possible. Folks were concerned to cull too many because the numbers were few. I understand that mindset. There was the constantly repeated quote showing the good trait of the breed ; “parasite resistance”. I call this type of startup a group or a breed of unimproved sheep. I tend to think that is the correct thing to say.
We are now in the 21st century. What progress has the St. Croix breed made beyond the early years?
#1 -Are we still able to truthfully say “parasite resistant”? Where is the proof? In the 80’s and 90’s during the time of breed expansion, it was often said that lambs required deworming one time. It was accepted. It created some St. Croix sheep that were not really resistant. If you test your sheep you will find out that the allowances in the past made the breed a bit weaker overall. Again, the phrase “unimproved breed”.
#2 – Do you have a clue as to the average carcass yield of your lambs? The average lamb in the USA is assumed to produce 50% of the live weight in the carcass. Debone that carcass and the amount of lamb meat is less. Do you palpate the loins and thighs of your lambs to have any idea of muscle thickness? Do you use scales to check periodic gains in total weight?
That 2nd quote at the start was speaking of ethnic buyers. They have bought and slaughtered sheep before. They are not stupid. They can tell more about your lambs than you can if you have not made any efforts to improve your sheep.
#3 – Price differential: March 4, 2026 Mt. Hope Auction, Mt. Hope, OH – The report was on Facebook today.
Lambs:
Prime 40-59 pounds $4.80 -5.27 (per pound)
Choice 40-59 pounds $4.40 – 4.77
_____* 40-59 pounds $3.90 – 4.37
*non-descript because they were not so good. These were “price take sheep”.
Reference from above: (David Fisher) “…didn’t want to just be a “price taker”
$0.90/pound difference from bottom to top. That is a difference of $36 to $53.10 per lamb. If you have twins from a ewe, that is a difference of $72 to over $106 per ewe. That is not chicken feed.
The St. Croix breed needs to modernize into an improved breed, a breed of predictable sheep and a meat sheep breed that actually produces meat and not just in a small % of the flocks in the USA. Without improvement, breed wide, you are merely a price taker: “They do not want straight sided sheep…” Lynn Fahrmeier
If you are doing nothing to improve your flock, you are not fooling buyers and consumers. You are fooling yourself.