Gray House Pies

Directions Website Contact the business
**THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE**\*Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004* # WE REGRET TO ANNOUNCE THE DEATH OF PIZ...
10/09/2026

**THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE**\
*Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004*

# WE REGRET TO ANNOUNCE THE DEATH OF PIZZA FRIDAY.

It is with considerable sadness that we announce the passing of Friday Night Detroit-Style Pizza at Gray House Pies.

Again.

Detroit-Style Pizza has died at Gray House at least five times over the past eight years.

Each time, we mourn its passing, reflect on what went wrong, and eventually decide that what the world really needs is another opportunity to buy our Detroit-Style Pizza.

And so we bring it back.

And so it dies again.

We are beginning to detect a pattern.

# # # FIRST, A WORD TO OUR PIZZA FANATICS.

We love you.

Seriously.

You have enthusiastically supported our Detroit-Style Pizza through every resurrection, every new topping, every revised menu, and every announcement that THIS TIME WE HAVE FIGURED IT OUT.

Some of you will undoubtedly write to tell us how much you love it and beg us to bring it back.

And we believe you.

The problem is that, according to our unofficial calculations, there are approximately 12 of you.

Wonderful people, all 12.

Unfortunately, we have yet to discover a business model in which 12 people can support an entire pizza operation.

# # # NOW, BEFORE ANYONE GETS THE WRONG IDEA...

**This is not your fault.**

We have made buying our pizza something of an obstacle course.

You couldn't build your own pizza.

We didn't deliver.

You had to order through our somewhat peculiar system.

And for our most recent incarnation, you had approximately two hours each week to purchase it.

We recognize that this is not exactly the business model employed by Domino's.

But here's the thing.

Over the years, we've also tried a full pizza menu. Multiple days of service. Different hours. Different formats. Different toppings.

We even opened an entire Detroit-Style Pizza shop.

An actual pizza shop.

With walls and everything.

We have given this particular idea more second chances than a Hollywood marriage.

# # # THE PROBLEM IS NOT THE PIZZA.

Pie Man loves pizza.

He loves making pizza. He loves eating pizza. He loves talking about pizza. He loves discussing dough hydration, fermentation, Wisconsin brick cheese, caramelized edges, and the structural advantages of a properly seasoned steel pan.

He can discuss these matters for considerably longer than anyone has ever requested.

And he especially loves Detroit-Style Pizza.

But there is one inconvenient detail about operating a business.

**Eventually, somebody has to make money.**

We can make terrific pizza. We can get enthusiastic compliments. We can even sell out on a Friday night.

But when we add up the ingredients, labor, preparation, cleanup, and all the other delightful expenses involved in making pizza, we simply haven't been able to make the numbers work consistently.

And we've tried.

For eight years.

At some point, even Pie Man has to acknowledge that the evidence is beginning to pile up.

# # # SO THIS IS GOODBYE.

To everyone who bought our pizzas, told their friends, brought their families, sent us compliments, or patiently listened to another explanation of why our dough needs three days in the refrigerator:

**Thank you.**

You made every one of our pizza experiments worth attempting.

We loved making pizza for you.

And although history suggests that we will eventually lose our minds and bring Detroit-Style Pizza back for a sixth time, we're going to resist making that announcement today.

For now, Friday Night Pizza is officially retired.

Please respect the family's privacy during this difficult time.

In lieu of flowers, the family requests that you purchase pies, sausage rolls, quiche, and other products that have demonstrated a greater willingness to contribute to the household finances.

**R.I.P. DETROIT-STYLE PIZZA.**

*Beloved by dozens.*

*Purchased regularly by approximately 12.*

*2018–2026. On and off.*

*Gone again, but never entirely out of the question.*

— your GHP pizza makers

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

**THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE**\*Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004* # PUMPKIN-PALOOZA!**ALL DAY FRIDAY & SAT...
10/09/2026

**THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE**\
*Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004*

# PUMPKIN-PALOOZA!

**ALL DAY FRIDAY & SATURDAY.**

Every October, America loses its collective mind over pumpkins.

We have traditionally observed this phenomenon from a safe distance, making pumpkin pies and pumpkin bread while other businesses introduce pumpkin-flavored toothpaste, pumpkin-scented automobile accessories, and pumpkin spice products for animals that have never expressed the slightest interest in pumpkins.

This year, however, we have decided to participate more aggressively.

Welcome to **PUMPKIN-PALOOZA**, two days during which Gray House Pies will attempt to put pumpkin into as many things as possible without attracting the attention of federal authorities.

Here's what we've come up with.

# # # OLD PIE MAN'S PUMPKIN PIE

Made from Old Pie Man's family recipe.

An actual family recipe, handed down through generations of people who apparently had no objection to sharing it with the next generation.

Fresh baked Friday and Saturday. The real deal.

# # # MRS. PIE MAN'S PUMPKIN BREAD

Available with or without chocolate chips.

This is Mrs. Pie Man's recipe.

Naturally, this raises several questions.

Who is Mrs. Pie Man?

Is she an actual person?

Does she bake?

Has anyone ever seen her?

Why has she remained largely absent from the Gray House Gazette despite her apparent contributions to the pumpkin bread industry?

We can confirm that Mrs. Pie Man exists, although she has wisely declined to participate in most of the activities described in these emails.

Her pumpkin bread is excellent.

# # # PUMPKIN GOOEY BUTTER CAKE

Gooey butter cake is an iconic St. Louis creation involving butter, sugar, cream cheese, and a rather casual attitude toward nutritional guidelines.

We have been making our own versions for years.

Now we've added pumpkin.

We realize that modifying a beloved regional specialty may upset certain residents of Missouri, but we believe the statute of limitations on cake modification has expired.

It's pumpkin. It's gooey. It's cake.

Our attorneys are comfortable with this.

# # # PUMPKIN CARAMEL CHEESE DANISH

Pumpkin. Cream cheese. Flaky pastry. Caramel.

We considered adding another ingredient, but the pastry was getting crowded.

# # # AND THEN THERE'S PUMPKIN BRÛLÉE.

This one requires an explanation.

*Brûlée* is a French word meaning "burnt," although the French have managed to make it sound considerably more sophisticated.

The idea is simple. Sprinkle sugar over something delicious, apply intense heat, and create a thin, brittle caramelized crust that cracks when you tap it with a spoon.

Wonderful.

There's just one problem.

**The crunchy part has a very short career.**

Moisture from the filling eventually softens the caramelized sugar. What begins as a magnificent sheet of edible glass gradually becomes a sticky coating.

This is why restaurants brûlée desserts immediately before serving them.

We tried it on pumpkin pie. It was terrific.

For about an hour.

Unfortunately, our large pies sometimes spend several days in your refrigerator, and selling a pie with a crunchy topping that has surrendered by breakfast seems like poor business practice.

**HOWEVER...**

We may be able to brûlée a pumpkin hand pie for you upon request, provided you plan to eat it fairly soon.

Think of it as a special-order, highly perishable architectural feature.

We are continuing our research.

---

**PUMPKIN-PALOOZA IS FRIDAY & SATURDAY ONLY.**

Fresh pumpkin pies, pumpkin bread, pumpkin gooey butter cake, and pumpkin caramel cheese danish.

Everything is being made in limited quantities.

Come early. Grab your favorites.

According to the National Bureau of Seasonal Food Coordination, quiche and pumpkin constitute a complete October dinner.

The bureau has no known employees, but its findings are encouraging.

**COME GET PUMPKINED.**

**Gray House Pies**\
*Keeping it flaky since 2004.*

Make the product list easier to scanTighten the brûlée sectionSharpen the opening joke

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

**Today only: Three Sausage Rolls for $6.05.**Why $6.05?Because $6 seemed too orderly, and apparently we are now chargin...
10/07/2026

**Today only: Three Sausage Rolls for $6.05.**

Why $6.05?

Because $6 seemed too orderly, and apparently we are now charging by whatever number wanders into our heads.

Three warm, flaky, pork-packed Sausage Rolls. Enough for lunch. Possibly enough to share, although we don’t know why you’d start making poor decisions now.

**Thursday only. Three for $6.05.**

Available in the shop while supplies last.

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

Are you on the GOOEY BUTTER CAKE band wagon???How about a FREE slice this WEDNESDAY??Huh, you don't even know what Gooey...
10/06/2026

Are you on the GOOEY BUTTER CAKE band wagon???

How about a FREE slice this WEDNESDAY??
Huh, you don't even know what Gooey Butter Cake is?!?
Oh no!

Gooey Butter Cake: the uproarious rockstar of American desserts, flaunting its sumptuous audacity like a dessert daredevil. Imagine a sugar-coated pillow fight between clouds and rainbows, with a gooey wrestling match in the center. It's the dessert that turned gooeyness into an art form, leaving taste buds swooning like teenage fans at a pop concert. This confectionery diva has a gravitational pull stronger than a black hole of yumminess, with fans declaring it the official currency of dessert utopia. So addictive, it should come with a warning label: "Caution - may induce uncontrollable cravings and enthusiastic air guitar solos."

A little over the top? Maybe. Maybe not!
Anyway, enjoy a free slice with any $10 purchase THIS WEDNESDAY ONLY (and only if you mention this message - only people in 'our circle'
get FREE GOOEY CAKE.)
(blah blah blah 'legal' stuff; not available with any other promotion, discount or giveaway)

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

******THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE***Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004* # IT ALL STARTS AT 5.Pizza Friday is ...
10/02/2026

****

**THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE**
*Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004*

# IT ALL STARTS AT 5.

Pizza Friday is here.

And tonight we once again unleash the newest member of our increasingly unruly Detroit pizza family:

# # # PHILLY CHEESESTEAK.

Shaved beef. Cheese. Peppers and onions. Thick, airy Detroit crust. Crispy caramelized cheese edges.

It's a cheesesteak.

It's a Detroit pizza.

Philadelphia and Detroit were not consulted.

**Pizza starts at 5.**

Order online now or just walk in and make decisions when you get here.

[ORDER PIZZA — Gray House Pies]

**GET IN HERE.**

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

**THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE***Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004* # IT'S 4:00. THIS IS YOUR PIZZA WARNING.A...
10/02/2026

**THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE**
*Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004*

# IT'S 4:00. THIS IS YOUR PIZZA WARNING.

At 5:00, **Pizza Friday begins.**

At 7:00, Pizza Friday ends.

Between those two times, you should probably acquire pizza.

Tonight we've got all the usual Detroit-style suspects, plus our new **Italian Sausage Pizza made with locally produced Italian sausage.**

# # # OFFICIAL PIZZA GUIDANCE

According to the **National Bureau of Friday Dinner Completion**, pizza by itself constitutes only **73% of a properly executed Friday night.**

Adding **Pumpkin Pie or Pumpkin Bread** raises Friday completion to somewhere in the neighborhood of **104%.**

We don't understand the math either.

But these are experts and pumpkin pie and pumpkin bread are in the House tonight!

**Add pumpkin to your pizza order tonight.**

**PREORDER NOW.**

Pizza at 5.

Dinner solved.

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

You can thank Diane for letting us know that our marketing guy has done it again: sending out a deal on FRIDAY that's on...
10/02/2026

You can thank Diane for letting us know that our marketing guy has done it again: sending out a deal on FRIDAY that's only good on THURSDAY (OMG, it's so ridiculously funny to read that last sentence. If it wasn't the boss sending out these, shall we say, 'oversights', we'd have to fire him. Anyway, no way we bring it to his attention on pizza Friday (his day of worship). So just come on in today (Friday) and enjoy the deal. If you see him, don't let him know we are honoring the deal today, We'll work some magic on the register so he doesn't catch on.
(ohhhh, he probably has this email scheduled to go out every Friday for the next decade, So, if you get one next Friday and the Friday after that etc., just come on in and give us the high sign that you're 'in the club' and get your sausage rolls and go.)

**Today only: Three Sausage Rolls for $6.05.**

Why $6.05?

Because $6 seemed too orderly, and apparently we are now charging by whatever number wanders into our heads.

Three warm, flaky, pork-packed Sausage Rolls. Enough for lunch. Possibly enough to share, although we don’t know why you’d start making poor decisions now.

**Thursday only. Three for $6.05.**

Available in the shop while supplies last.

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

**Today only: Three Sausage Rolls for $6.05.**Why $6.05?Because $6 seemed too orderly, and apparently we are now chargin...
10/02/2026

**Today only: Three Sausage Rolls for $6.05.**

Why $6.05?

Because $6 seemed too orderly, and apparently we are now charging by whatever number wanders into our heads.

Three warm, flaky, pork-packed Sausage Rolls. Enough for lunch. Possibly enough to share, although we don’t know why you’d start making poor decisions now.

**Thursday only. Three for $6.05.**

Available in the shop while supplies last.

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

**THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE**  *Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004* # PUMPKIN SEASON IS HERE.You know what ...
10/02/2026

**THE GRAY HOUSE GAZETTE**

*Keeping Cleveland Questionably Informed Since 2004*

# PUMPKIN SEASON IS HERE.

You know what this means.

For the next two months, America will require **pumpkin in absolutely everything.**

Pumpkin coffee.
Pumpkin b**r.
Pumpkin cereal.
Pumpkin bagels.
Pumpkin cream cheese.
Pumpkin yogurt.
Pumpkin oatmeal.
Pumpkin pancakes.
Pumpkin waffles.
Pumpkin donuts.
Pumpkin cookies.
Pumpkin cheesecake.
Pumpkin ice cream.
Pumpkin hummus.
Pumpkin salsa.
Pumpkin pasta sauce.
Pumpkin ravioli.
Pumpkin potato chips.
Pumpkin pretzels.
Pumpkin popcorn.
Pumpkin protein powder.
Pumpkin dog treats.
Pumpkin candles.
Pumpkin soap.
Pumpkin shampoo.
Pumpkin deodorant.
Pumpkin lip balm.
Pumpkin air freshener.

We assume somewhere in America there is already a product called **Pumpkin Spice Windshield Washer Fluid**, formulated to give your car that warm autumn feeling while removing dead insects.

At Gray House, we're showing considerably more restraint.

So far.

# # # PUMPKIN PIE

The original. Pumpkin's legitimate reason for becoming famous in the first place.

# # # PUMPKIN BREAD

Also perfectly reasonable. We checked.

# # # PUMPKIN PASTRY CREAM

This is where things begin to drift slightly.

All three are now appearing at Gray House in **limited quantities.** We're easing into pumpkin season rather than immediately converting the building into a giant orange squash.

Grab some while they're here.

And while you're doing that, you may notice something else happening tonight.

# # # PIZZA FRIDAY. 5–7 PM.

This has absolutely nothing to do with pumpkins.

We just needed a segue.

Preorder your Detroit-style pizzas now, then grab some pumpkin stuff when you pick them up tonight.

Pizza for dinner.

Pumpkin for dessert.

**Fall has apparently been handled.**

[ORDER ONLINE — Gray House Pies](grayhousepies.com?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

Click here for an update from Gray House Pies!

Address

26075 Detroit Road
Westlake, OH
44145

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10:30am - 6:30pm
Wednesday 10:30am - 6:30pm
Thursday 10:30am - 6:30pm
Friday 10:30am - 6:30pm
Saturday 9am - 4pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Gray House Pies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Gray House Pies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category