BenTheBaker

Specialty pie shop with Take & Bake Items (pies, mini-pies) and Thaw & Serve Items (pies, cheesecake
(1)

08/31/2026

***** NEW FLAVOR ALERT - SEVEN-LAYER BAR PIE!! *****
We have another new flavor to release...Seven-Layer Bar Pie! If you've never had Seven-Layer Bars at a Minnesota potluck, you need to start attending potlucks more often. This is an extrmely rich dessert that we tweaked a little bit to get into pie form and cut down a tad on the sweetness. Check out the full description below and place your preorder for this weekend! We'll be closed on Labor Day, so Saturday will be your last chance to stock up on pie until Tuesday :-)
***** Seven-Layer Bar Pie - Thaw & Serve *****
***** Regular - $38 *****
***** GF Graham - $42 *****
The indulgent Seven Layer Bars you grew up with, but now in pie form! The seven "layers" are traditionally graham crackers, butter, chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, walnuts, shredded coconut, and sweetened condensed milk. We prefer the flavor of toasted pecans to walnuts, so we swapped those out and doubled the ratio of nuts in the recipe. We also subbed in evaporated milk for a portion of the sweetened condensed milk to help cut down a bit more on the sweetness. It's still a decadent pie, but not so sweet that you can't finish a piece or two in one sitting!
***** Walk-in/Pickup Times *****
Friday, September 4th (2pm-6pm)
Saturday, September 5th (10am-6pm)
***** Preorder Form *****
https://form.jotform.com/262426493456161
***** Website *****
www.BenTheBaker.com
***** Bakery Location *****
4522 Otter Lake Road, White Bear Lake, MN 55110

08/25/2026

***** NEW FLAVOR ALERT - LEMON SUPREME PIE!! *****
Sorry for the short notice, but we just finished up a new recipe to release for this weekend: Lemon Supreme Pie! I have had a few customers ask for this pie over the years -- I think Baker's Square used to make it and there are a few recipes floating around the internet. Through some trial-and-error I made a version that we really like here! The filling is not too different than our Raspberry Pretzel Pie, a whipped cheesecake variation, but it has a higher ratio of cream cheese so it's a bit richer and then you fold in whipped cream to lighten it. The topping is lemon cream, which is the same filling we make for our Lemon Meringue Pie. A combination of fresh-squeezed lemon juice, egg yoks, sugar, salt, and cornstarch to thicken it. We like it a bit tart, but not over-the-top tart, so give it a try if that sounds good to you!
***** Lemon Supreme Pie - Baked Fresh *****
***** Regular - $38 *****
***** GF Graham - $42 *****
This light, refreshing pie starts with our all-butter flaky pie crust that gets filled with our whipped cheesecake filling and topped with our tart lemon cream made from fresh-squeezed lemons. We like our lemon cream on the tart side, hopefully you do too!
***** Walk-in/Pickup Times *****
Friday, August 28th (2pm-6pm)
Saturday, August 29th (10am-6pm)
***** Preorder Form *****
https://form.jotform.com/262365251605151
***** Website *****
www.BenTheBaker.com
***** Bakery Location *****
4522 Otter Lake Road, White Bear Lake, MN 55110

08/17/2026

***** UPDATE - Sold out, thank you! - DISCOUNT PIES!!! *****
We made just a few too many Chocolate Banana Cream Pies, so we are offering 25% off of the 2 regular and 1 gluten free ones we have left. We made these Friday, so the crust starts to soften a bit over time in the fridge, but they should still be good through Wednesday or Thursday I'd say. Post below if you'd like to reserve one, just be sure to write if you want regular or GF and whether you want pickup today 10am-6pm or tomorrow 10am-6pm. I'll reply to your comment to lock it in!
** SOLD! ** - Regular, was $38, now $28.50
** SOLD! ** - Gluten Free, was $42, now $31.50

08/10/2026

***** DISCOUNT PIE!!! -- SOLD OUT, THANKS! *****

We have just a few Haupia Pies leftover from Saturday and we are selling them 25% off since the graham crust gets a bit softer after a couple days in the fridge. You'll probably want to finish this pie by Wednesday or Thursday for best quality.

We only have 2 regular Haupia Pies left (price was $38, now $28.50) and 1 Gluten Free Haupia Pas (price was $42, now $31.50). Post below if you'd like to reserve one for pickup! Just write in your post if you want pickup today or tomorrow 10am-6pm and I'll reply to your post to lock it in.

***** Haupia Pie - Baked Fresh *****
This is our take on a popular Hawaiian pie that traditionally uses half coconut milk and half regular milk, along with a bit of chocolate, to make a beautiful layered pie. We thought the coconut flavor wasn't coming through strongly enough though, so we use 100% coconut milk. We add in Ghirardelli bittersweet chocolate for the chocolate layer, top the pie with whipped cream and toasted coconut, and nestle it in all inside our graham cracker crumb crust. The flavor reminds me of a certain chocolate-covered coconut candy bar that I used to trade for on Halloween night when we'd get back from trick-or-treating

08/07/2026

We made a few extra Haupia Pies for the weekend! Drop by today by 6pm or tomorrow 10am-6pm. Message me to reserve one if you'd like, or take your chances and just stop in!

***** Haupia Pie - Baked Fresh *****
***** Regular - $38 *****
***** Gluten Free - $42 *****
This is our take on a popular Hawaiian pie that traditionally uses half coconut milk and half regular milk, along with a bit of chocolate, to make a beautiful layered pie. We thought the coconut flavor wasn't coming through strongly enough though, so we use 100% coconut milk. We add in Ghirardelli bittersweet chocolate for the chocolate layer, top the pie with whipped cream and toasted coconut, and nestle it in all inside our graham cracker crumb crust. The flavor reminds me of a certain chocolate-covered coconut candy bar that I used to trade for on Halloween night when we'd get back from trick-or-treating 🙂

08/03/2026

***** NEW PIE FLAVOR - HAUPIA PIE!! *****
We're adding another pie flavor to our rotation -- Haupia Pie! I had never heard of this pie until a few weeks ago, but if you like coconut and chocolate you're gonna love this pie. We'll make just one batch of these for the weekend, so check out the description below and place your preorder to lock one down!
***** Haupia Pie - Baked Fresh *****
***** Regular - $38 *****
***** Gluten Free - $42 *****
This is our take on a popular Hawaiian pie that traditionally uses half coconut milk and half regular milk, along with a bit of chocolate, to make a beautiful layered pie. We thought the coconut flavor wasn't coming through strongly enough though, so we use 100% coconut milk. We add in Ghirardelli bittersweet chocolate for the chocolate layer, top the pie with whipped cream and toasted coconut, and nestle it in all inside our graham cracker crumb crust. The flavor reminds me of a certain chocolate-covered coconut candy bar that I used to trade for on Halloween night when we'd get back from trick-or-treating :-)
***** Walk-in/Pickup Times *****
Friday, August 7th (2pm-6pm)
Saturday, August 8th (10am-6pm)
***** Preorder Form *****
https://form.jotform.com/262146358076158
***** Website *****
www.BenTheBaker.com
***** Bakery Location *****
4522 Otter Lake Road, White Bear Lake, MN 55110

07/30/2026

Thanks for trying us out! Some good flavor picks there :-D

07/27/2026

***** Pie of the Weekend - Chocolate Espresso Pie!! *****
If you're the kind of person who loves your iced mocha lattes when it's hot out, then you'll want to order one of our Chocolate Espresso Pies! We haven't made this pie since Mother's Day weekend, so this might be your last chance for the year to get one!
***** Chocolate Espresso Pie - Baked Fresh *****
Regular - $38
Gluten Free - $42
This pie starts with an Oreo crumb crust, followed by a rich chocolate pastry cream layer made with Ghirardelli chocolate, followed by an espresso chiffon layer (whipped egg whites folded into a espresso pastry cream), and topped with freshly whipped cream and chocolate curls.
***** Walk-in/Pickup Times *****
Friday, July 31st (2pm-6pm)
Saturday, August 1st (10am-6pm)
***** Preorder Form *****
https://form.jotform.com/262076344027151
***** Website *****
www.BenTheBaker.com
***** Bakery Location *****
4522 Otter Lake Road, White Bear Lake, MN 55110

07/24/2026

***** Christmas in July - Peppermint Christmas Pie!! *****
It's Christmas in July! We made extra Peppermint Christmas Pies and slices for walk-ins today and tomorrow. Drop on by and get one to surprise your family this weekend!
***** Peppermint Christmas Pie - Thaw & Serve *****
***** Regular - $38 *****
***** Gluten Free - $42 *****
For the candy cane lovers! We fill our Oreo crumb crust with a layer of French silk, then a layer of peppermint white chocolate French silk with sprinkles and crushed candy cane pieces folded in, then a thin layer of whipped chocolate ganache, and top it with whipped cream and more sprinkles!
***** Walk-in/Pickup Times *****
Friday, July 24th (2pm-6pm)
Saturday, July 25th (10am-6pm).
***** Website *****
www.BenTheBaker.com
***** Bakery Location *****
4522 Otter Lake Road, White Bear Lake, MN 55110

07/18/2026

***** Christmas in July - Peppermint Christmas Pie!! *****
It's Christmas in July! We created our Peppermint Christmas Pie recipe last Christmas and it was so popular we couldn't make enough of them to keep up with demand at the time. We figured we'd make a one-time batch of them in the middle of July for you all in case you missed out :-)
***** Peppermint Christmas Pie - Thaw & Serve *****
***** Regular - $38 *****
***** Gluten Free - $42 *****
For the candy cane lovers! We fill our Oreo crumb crust with a layer of French silk, then a layer of peppermint white chocolate French silk with sprinkles and crushed candy cane pieces folded in, then a thin layer of whipped chocolate ganache, and top it with whipped cream and more sprinkles!
***** Walk-in/Pickup Times *****
Friday, July 24th (2pm-6pm)
Saturday, July 25th (10am-6pm)
***** Preorder Form *****
https://form.jotform.com/261983690830163
***** Website *****
www.BenTheBaker.com
***** Bakery Location *****
4522 Otter Lake Road, White Bear Lake, MN 55110

Address

4522 Otter Lake Road
White Bear Lake, MN
55110

Telephone

+16513374076

Website

http://www.BenTheBaker.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when BenTheBaker posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to BenTheBaker:

Want your business to be the top-listed Food & Beverage Service in White Bear Lake?