02/12/2026
Weâve been getting questions for 10+ years about why we donât have LGDs (livestock guardian dogs) here. We donât need one, first and foremost, we donât know enough about them, and we ::definitely:: do not have a property that is LGD-ready.
Rant alert because the day started, once again, with a request to take a dog, consult on another (always happy to do that), and possibly assist a rescue...
Itâs time again ⌠like it wasnât ever actually time anywhere along the way⌠to remind folks getting into homesteading, farming, ranching, farm steading, co-op land stewardship, agritourism with critters to pet, agritourism without crittersâŚ.that you VERY likely do NOT need a livestock guardian dogâŚnot a Pyrenees, not an Anatolian, not a Kangal, not a Karakachan, not a not-an-actual-LGD Colorado Mountain Dog. STOP ACQUIRING THESE DOGS ONLY TO TAP OUT WHEN THE GOING GETS TOUGH!
Now I know what youâre gonna say⌠âthe (insert list of usual suspects in the way predators) are unaliving my (chickens or insert the livestock you keep or plan to acquire)â OR âI hear coyotes almost every night and Iâm pretty sure there are several dozen. Itâs very unsettling and I lost some chickens last week.â
Itâs admirable that you want to keep your animals safe and protect them from the wildlife thatâs just trying to surviveâŚor from your neighborâs perpetually at large dog(s) that are constantly crapping up your place and trying to unalive the (fill in the blank with type of animals you keep).
HOWEVER - the reality is that a livestock guardian dog is NOT an easy button solution to your predator management issues. It requires sound fencing and training/guidance to make up a puppy into a mature, working, dependable guardian. You cannot just throw said LGD puppy out with your stock, offer a âgood luck, yâall,â and walk away expecting success. These dogs are DOGS, first and foremost, and go through alllll the same stages as any dogâŚpuppyhood, adolescence, and finally mature adult. Just like a humanoid crotch spawn, these dogs require guidance and training (didnât I just say that?) especially during adolescence.
Rescues continue to tread water while being SWAMPED with requests to take in âfailedâ LGDâŚusually Pyrenees, simply because they are the most common breed in North America. These dogs are not usually failuresâŚmost of the time they have been failed by humans who didnât have a clue about what they were getting into. Either they didnât do sufficient research or were given bad info by someone trying to sell puppies. Here are a few of the most common reasons rescue gets called upon to take these alleged failuresâŚ.
Item 1: The dog wonât stay in the fencing...usually because itâs insufficient, they donât respect it, and itâs self-rewarding to escape and go on walkaboutsâŚguess who couldâve prevented/fixed that with better fencing?
Item 2: This dog harasses/maims/unalives poultry and stockâŚbecause theyâve maybe been tossed into the melee without structure/guidance/trainingâŚguess whose responsibility it was to provide the aforementioned?
Item 3: This dog just loves to wander; I canât keep it home!âŚsee Item 1.
Item 4: The dog is âfood aggressiveââŚthis is just plain & simple resource guarding and is so common in LGDs sometimes I think it should just be listed as a breed trait. Guess whose job it is to make sure the dog can eat without having to defend its food from nosy goats and marauding chickensâŚor keep the children away from the dogâŚor teach the dog from the time itâs a puppy that it doesnât own everything?
Item 5: The dog is boisterous and jumps and bounces and knocks over my kids. Guess whose job it was to teach the puppy to keep all 4 on the floor when it was still small enough for you to most effectively and easily teach that?
Item 6: The dog barks all the timeâŚit barks all night and my neighbors are calling the law on us! Guess who shouldâve done their research ahead of time to understand that barking at predators/perceived threats as a warning to go away is the LGDâs first line of defense?
EVERY single week I am asked to take in or assist with 3-4 LGDs somewhere in the United States. Not just locallyâŚshelters, humane societies, other rescues who are just trying to save these dogs from the needle when they inevitably end up in the shelter because people tap out and canât find situations for themâŚNew Mexico, Oregon, Texas, Tennessee, California, Ohio, Nebraska, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Virginia, Kentucky, and, of course, North CarolinaâŚand thatâs just the places represented by calls/emails/texts since last October. I am one individual doing LGD rescueâŚthe 501c3 rescues are insanely overwhelmed. There is NOWHERE to put the adolescent LGD that you acquired and now want to tap out on. We are struggling to find suitable homes for the made dogsâŚand, no, you canât just let the dog wander your ten acres that backs up to public land so it can protect your forty free range chickens and two pet goats.
There is a lot of misinformation out in the Wild West of the Interwebz as it relates to these dogsâŚlots of folks with a platform to spew their wrong advice; lots of yahoos peddling puppies from questionable parents with zero health clearances, poor hips, bad coats, and inconsistent temperaments. We recommend Learning About LGDs Facebook group for best practices advice and information. Join that group and LEARN what to expect from this lifelong commitment to a giant barking & shedding machine that has been bred for 1000s of years to do its job independent of direction (aka youâre not the boss of me, Brenda, I got thisâŚ).
And while youâre doing the deep dive and learning all you can about these dogs, employee one or all of the following to manage predators BEFORE considering the LGD:
Electric fencing, fladry, motion lights, solar powered predator eye lights, portable radio, predator urine, motion sensor sprinkler systems (only suitable for no freeze climates), and any other sketchy looking accoutrement that you can move around that makes your livestock area seem unstable and risky to predators. If you try all of that and still canât deter the predators (domestic dogs wonât care about any of the above except the electric fencing- they are not risk averse), THEN consider an LGD and go about it the right way. The right way does NOT include Craigslist, Tractor Supply bulletin board, randoms in the WalMart parking lot, or backyard breeders generating revenue by producing puppies from parents with zero health clearances.
Iâm sure all of this sounds really bossy pants, âwhy donât you mind your own business, Joy,â and harsh but, seriously, yâallâŚIt becomes my business when you ask me to take on your 9 month old Thor or Luna that is unruly and off the rails because of no guidance/training. Those of us doing rescue cannot continue to absorb all of the dogs that too many people seem to feel are just disposable farm equipment âŚand weâre sick of seeing them euthanized at alarming rates all across the country. Every breed specific rescue I know, Bluebonnet in Texas, Big Fluffy Dog in Tennessee continue to do what they can and yet the calls to take these dogs just keep coming
And let me also be clear⌠Backyard breeders & Unethical Puppy Producers (your AKC papers mean jack when you dump that litter of BWD puppies at the local shelterâŚwe see you every time you do this!)âŚthis problem rests squarely on yâallâs shoulders as much as it does the unequipped newbs. Randomly produced LGD shouldnât be a revenue stream on your homestead, I do NOT care what the power point at the national conference said.
DO BETTER.
Picture for the taxâŚthis is the infamous Hazel, our fabulous guard anything Pyr who came here 7 years ago at 7 months old after her owner determined that she wasnât suitable for life in an apartment. Thatâs right, Hazel was a rescue. It took a year + to finish her to a dependable, working dog. Sadly â due to unethical breeding â Hazel struggle with mild hip dysplasia, a degenerative process that will eventually render her to unsound to do the job she loves.