Butter and Batter by Caitlyn

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Butter and Batter by Caitlyn Butter and Batter by Caitlyn is a homemade cookie and cake business based in New Concord, Ohio, specializing in fresh, delicious treats made with love.

09/15/2026

🤍 A HUGE thank you to everyone who has supported my small business! 🤍

What started as something small has become so much more meaningful to me. Being a stay-at-home mom of 3, with my youngest only 5 months old, I started this business during a season of postpartum life where I really needed something that was just for me.

Baking has become my little outlet — something that gives me a chance to be creative, feel productive, and have something of my own while still being home with my babies. 🥹🧁

Every order, share, like, comment, recommendation, and repeat customer means more to me than you know. You’re not just supporting a business — you’re supporting a mama who is trying to build something for herself while raising her three babies.

I’m so incredibly grateful for every single person who has trusted me with your orders. Thank you for allowing me to do what I love and for helping me grow Butter & Batter by Caitlyn. 🤍

Here’s to continuing to grow, bake, and build this little dream of mine! 🍪🎂

🍪🍰 Everything Box — $60Includes:* 1 of every cookie flavor (8 cookies)* 1 of every mini cake flavor (5 mini cakes)* 13 t...
09/14/2026

🍪🍰 Everything Box — $60

Includes:

* 1 of every cookie flavor (8 cookies)
* 1 of every mini cake flavor (5 mini cakes)
* 13 treats total

🍪 The Cookie Collection- $28
Includes :
* 1 of every cookie flavor (8 cookies)

The Mini Cake Flight ✈️🍰 - $30
Includes :
* 1 of every mini cake

Cookie cart out today ! 10-81410 N 11th Street. Cambridge
09/13/2026

Cookie cart out today ! 10-8

1410 N 11th Street. Cambridge

NEW FLAVOR ALERT - LIMITED 🎃 pumpkin 🎃With cream cheese icing , available in mini cakes or cookies!
09/12/2026

NEW FLAVOR ALERT - LIMITED

🎃 pumpkin 🎃

With cream cheese icing , available in mini cakes or cookies!

Our first cookie cart ever is in Zanesville today until 9pm ! 811 Larzelere Ave
08/30/2026

Our first cookie cart ever is in Zanesville today until 9pm !
811 Larzelere Ave

❤️ BAKING FOR HOOPER ❤️In memory of our best friend, Kyler “Hoop” Hooper, we are putting together a special Cookies & Mi...
08/30/2026

❤️ BAKING FOR HOOPER ❤️

In memory of our best friend, Kyler “Hoop” Hooper, we are putting together a special Cookies & Mini Cakes Sale to help support Hoopers family. 🕊️❤️

Every cookie and mini cake purchased will help make a difference for Kaci and her family during this incredibly difficult time.

📍 Crispy’s Barber Lounge
2895 Maysville Pike, Zanesville, OH 43701
📅 Wednesday–Friday
⏰ During business hours

Come grab something sweet, show your support, and help us honor Hoop’s memory. ❤️

Even if you do not want a cookie or a mini cake we will accept donations also! every last dime will go DIRECTLY to Kaci ❤️

Every purchase makes a difference.
Long Live Hoop. 🕊️❤️

08/22/2026

✨ EXCITING NEWS IS COMING! ✨

I’ve been working on something behind the scenes, and I am SO excited to finally share it with you all! 🥹💗

Something new is coming to Butter & Batter by Caitlyn… 👀🍪🧁

I’m not ready to spill all the details just yet, but trust me—you’re going to want to keep an eye out! 🤭✨

BIG ANNOUNCEMENT COMING SOON! 💕

08/17/2026

Don’t forget to get your orders in !!

Address

1165 Newark Rd, Zanesville, OH 43701-2618, United States
Zanesville, OH
43701-2618

Telephone

+17406304141

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Butter and Batter by Caitlyn posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Butter and Batter by Caitlyn:

Shortcuts

Share

Category