Rate My Reuben

Directions Website

Rate My Reuben We are searching for the perfect Reuben. The King of all sandwiches! This page is dedicated to helping us find that perfect Reuben Sandwich!

Born in Wisconsin, on a mission to find the best Reuben ANYWHERE! 🥪🚗The Reubenator may call Wisconsin home, but our sear...
10/19/2026

Born in Wisconsin, on a mission to find the best Reuben ANYWHERE! 🥪🚗

The Reubenator may call Wisconsin home, but our search for the ultimate Reuben knows no state lines. From small-town diners to big-city delis, we're hitting the road one sandwich at a time!

📍 Where should the Reubenator head next? Drop your favorite Reuben spot in the comments! 👇

Some foods are meant to be shared… a great Reuben is one of them 👀🥪
10/15/2026

Some foods are meant to be shared… a great Reuben is one of them 👀🥪

🚨 REUBEN MODE: ON. 🚨Crispy rye. Corned beef. Melty Swiss. Sauerkraut. Dressing. The essentials are all here.Now there's ...
10/12/2026

🚨 REUBEN MODE: ON. 🚨

Crispy rye. Corned beef. Melty Swiss. Sauerkraut. Dressing. The essentials are all here.

Now there's only one question: Where should the Reubenator go next? Drop your favorite Reuben spot in the comments. 👇

10/10/2026

This is my second review here at Inventors. They asked to give it another try as they had worked on improving their Reuben. It did not disappoint!

The Reubenator has spoken!Gala Resort in Fremont, WI, came in strong with 4.6 out of 5 elbow slams, earning premium-tier...
10/08/2026

The Reubenator has spoken!

Gala Resort in Fremont, WI, came in strong with 4.6 out of 5 elbow slams, earning premium-tier status. And that corned beef? Made in-house 👏

Think it deserves the score? Check out the full review at https://vmkt.co/4y6lijV!

10/08/2026

🥪 RATE MY REUBEN | THE ROAD TO REUBEN GLORY — STEVENS POINT!

🚨 THE ROAD TO REUBEN GLORY JUST GOT A LITTLE MORE ACADEMIC! 🎓🥪🔨

The Reubenator rolled into Jordan Bar in Stevens Point, Wisconsin, and this time, he brought some serious backup!

Joining the hunt were Marty Loy, UW–Stevens Point Provost and official RMR Field Agent, and Dr. Scott Wallace, UWSP Professor of Economics!

What happens when you combine a legendary sandwich quest, a university provost, an economics professor, and a man obsessed with finding the perfect Reuben?

A whole lot of delicious research! 😂

We’re not just rating sandwiches. We’re celebrating the people, places, and communities that make Wisconsin extraordinary.

🎥 WATCH THE REVIEW! Did Jordan Bar bring us one step closer to the elusive PERFECT 5.0?

👇 YOUR MISSION: Tag a restaurant serving a legendary Reuben! The Reubenator might just show up next!

⭐ THE ROAD TO REUBEN GLORY CONTINUES! ⭐

10/07/2026

🚨 THE ROAD TO REUBEN GLORY ROLLS INTO MADISON 🥪⭐

This time, The Reubenator takes the Velvet Hammer to The Coopers Tavern — right on Capitol Square — where their “famous Reuben” has built a following of its own.

House-braised corned beef. Scotch Ale–soaked sauerkraut. Swiss. Thousand Island. Grilled black rye.

But reputation doesn’t earn the stars. The sandwich does. 🔨

So… how close does Coopers get to Reuben Glory?

🎥 Watch the review. Drop YOUR score in the comments. And tag the Wisconsin Reuben we need to hunt down next.

The Road to Reuben Glory continues. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Consider this your sign to treat yourself 🥪🔥 A perfectly stacked Reuben is always a good idea.
10/05/2026

Consider this your sign to treat yourself 🥪🔥 A perfectly stacked Reuben is always a good idea.

The anatomy of a great Reuben.Tender corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, melty Swiss, and that all-important dressing. When e...
10/01/2026

The anatomy of a great Reuben.

Tender corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, melty Swiss, and that all-important dressing. When every layer pulls its weight, you know you're in for a good one.

What's the most important part of a Reuben to you? 👇

Address

137 Maple
Hartland, WI
53029

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Rate My Reuben posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category