https://www.facebook.com/100738264761208/

Potato skin reviews

Home
United States
Henryville, IN
Potato skin reviews

Reviewer of all things potato skins

10/15/2026

Happy Fall ya’ll! I was scarred by that By Golly review that it’s taken a while to find some potato skins. I seriously have wiped out the potato skin market in Louisville & Southern Indiana. Today’s review is from Joe Huber Farm & Restaurant located in Starlight Indiana. I always used to visit Joe Huber’s as a kid in grade school. They have a great winery, cheese shop, petting zoo, and the food is good too. Probably should plan a visit and take my little potato skins. I was shocked when the full plate arrived, I was expecting an odd number and tiny potatoes. This order was MASSIVE!! The potatoes were so large that I could only eat one. I’d compare them in size to the ones at Fireside Bar & Grill in Sellersburg Indiana. Along with being massive, the potatoes were thick too, making think they were going to be raw or not cooked all the way through. Grabbed my fork and knife and cut through like butter, no thick spots. Not sure how they did that because I jabbed all the potatoes and they were cooked all the way through. My first bite and it was a bite I’ve been missing for a while. They did not skimp on the cheese or bacon, every bite was covered. The saltiness of the bacon stood out, no table salt needed. Again, these potatoes were so large I could only eat one and I would 100% order these again in a heartbeat. The order cost $10.99, based on the size along it’s a solid RoP. Ranch was ordered, just not photographed, it was OK, nothing to write home about. If there were scallions on the order, this order would be in the top 10 category. Happy to score this order at 4.5 out of 5 🥔. 🥔 🧀 🥓 🔥 What is this BS of only being able to add 5 tags Zuckerberg??

01/18/2026

Visited my local with a short list of items needed and my PSR was triggered (potato skin radar). In between the bacon wrapped jalapeños and the cheese curds, my eyes were drawn to an unbranded box of potato skins for $13.99. There’s at least 25-30 in the box so excellent ROP. 360° for 10 minutes in the air fryer will do the trick, I let them sit in there an extra couple of minutes. These were excellent! Plenty of cheese throughout, but the saltiness of the bacon really stood out and hit the spot. I’m not sure who the manufacturer is but I think these beat out the last Costco frozen brand I had. I topped a couple of them off with a cracked pepper ranch from .valley chefs kiss. 100% would get again and probably should have purchased 2 boxes. 4.7 out of 5 🥔. I’m limited to 5 hashtags, what gives Zuckerberg??

11/21/2025

By golly it’s been a minute since there’s been a review, but I finally found another restaurant that has potato skins. is a chain out of Ohio that opened a location in Clarksville Indiana. I was invited to their grand opening in September and let’s just say it wasn’t a grand first visit. The second photo is the order of potato skins I got on September 6th. I waited 50 minutes for the order, unfortunately the entire order was ice cold. Someone must have set them somewhere, found them 30 minutes later and then served them to me. I let the manager know I’d be back after they work their kinks out. Order looked good though, I think it was the first time I described a potato as voluptuous. Plenty of bacon, and scallions actually included on the order, just wish it wasn’t cold. Fast forward 2 months later and it’s time for another visit. I think I would have rather eaten the cold order than the order I had today. $12.95 for the order of 6, $2.16 per skin, not the best ROP. When I got in the car, all I could smell was scallions. I opened the lid and was surprised to see an order of scallions with a side of potatoes. This order looked nothing like the one from 2 months ago. WHERE’S THE BACON??? I picked up the first skin and it’s just barely warm. First bite and I’m already turned off. It was like a potato in a casing, some soft and raw spots wrapped in potato skin. I could only eat 2 of these they were that bad. Salt was definitely needed since they left the bacon off. The cheese was flavorless and acted as a skin on top of the potato. I wonder if these were just plucked out of a freezer bag and thrown into the fryer? Sour cream comes with the order, of course I got ranch though. It was nothing to write home about. Good to check this location off the list as I won’t be making a return visit. This order gets a 1.1 out of 5 🥔.

07/13/2025

I’m pretty sure I’ve tried all the potato skins in Louisville and Southern Indiana. I had traveled to Henryville Indiana for a round of golf at and low and behold they had potato skins on their menu. After a dumpster fire round of 110, I ate my feelings with an order of their potato skins. The online menu says $9 for the order, but I was charged $12 for 6 small skins. Some of these skins were a 1 bite potato. Not a good RoP. There was real bacon included on this order. It had a flat top/cooked on a grill flavor to it which I found really interesting. The potatoes were evenly scooped, but they were frozen potato halves like you find at GFS in bulk. There was a melted cheese blend for this order, but needed more. Not looking for a cheese pull, but need more than just a dusting. There were scallions on the order, but I think they were dried and get sprinkled on for show. Sour cream came on the side, but I slacked and forgot to ask for a side of ranch. Maybe ranch would have helped with the score. Happy to have tried this order, but I’m probably skipping these next time and getting the cheese curds. This review comes in at 2.1 out of 5 🥔. ⛳️

02/01/2025

Is this the first international potato skin review?? Hello from Holland 👋 (Michigan) and the Passing through with my future potato skin reviewer, Beechwood Grill was the first to come up when I googled “Potato skins near me.” We stopped by Friday night and it was so busy that we decide to come back for lunch the next day. The restaurant alone was huge and glad we returned the next day. We opted for an order of their cheese curds and potato skins of course. 5 skins for $10.50, not bad on the RoP. Overall size of these potatoes was really impressive, this was a fork and knife order they were that large. When the order arrived, you could smell the bacon right away. This is a real steakhouse and the bacon matched the energy. That first bite the bacon let me know it was the star of the review, smokey goodness. Besides being so large, the potatoes were scooped well, no thick spots found in this entire order. Real sharp shredded cheese was used and plenty of it. And can we say hello to scallions for this order, it’s been a minute since those have made an order. The ranch was really good too, no industrial taste at, could be speculation that they make it in house. I feel like steakhouses do pretty well when it comes to potato skins and Beechwood Grill knocked it out of the park with this order. I’d like to have that 6th potato skin as part of the order, but I’m putting this review in my all time top 7 reviews. 4.7 out of 5 🥔.

12/09/2024

2024 is quickly coming to an end, time to hit the potato skin reviews hard.

Found myself in Southern Indiana last week around lunchtime, so of course I Googled “potato skins near me” and Hunter Station Pizza Sellersburg was the first option to pop up. Located in Sellersburg Indiana, Hunter Station is large restaurant with outdoor seating and good menu to pick from. The waitress brought over a menu and told her I was here for 1 thing and 1 thing only, potato skins! $9.99 for an order of 6 skins, but I received 8 so that’s a good start. The order came out piping hot with a large side of ranch. My first bite in and I’m intrigued and satisfied at the same time. The cheese got me going first, this tri cheese blend, a good mix of pizza cheese. I can’t confirm but I’m almost positive they have a pizza conveyor oven. The overflow of cheese was melted and crispy at the same time, this really stood out to me and was a really good feature to this review. The bacon was cooked properly and tasted like actual bacon. Potatoes were good sized and scooped pretty evenly, only a couple of skins with thick spots. I’m loving my first bites, potato cooked all the way through with that cheese standing out. Making my way through the order, there were just a couple spuds that might have needed a little extra time on the conveyor to cook all the way through. I know this isn’t a ranch specific account, but damn this was some good ranch here. I would definitely come back to try other items on the menu, but would always come back for the potato skins. Happy to give this a review of 4.0 out of 5 🥔. 🥔 🧀 🥓 🔥

08/20/2023

To those who celebrate, Happy National Potato Day! New review coming tomorrow.

08/18/2023

Official back to school week potato skin review! So glad we have made it to Friday. Make sure to have some potato skins ready for the kiddos getting off the bus. Stopped in the other day to with Mrs. Potatoskin. First time here and ready for a return visit to try the other menu items. Wings were really good here as were the spicy cheese curds, definitely would get again. I want to try the cornmeal dusted pickle chips and the stinky chips next time. 6 good size skins for this order, coming in at $9.99, not a bad RoP. The overall size of the skins required them to be eaten with a fork and a knife, really good sign! First bite and I instantly knew I would come back again for these. It was the perfect bite of crispy potato, bacon, cheese and scallions/green onions. They definitely did not skimp out on the bacon, plenty to go around with extra pieces to clean up on the plate. They did something really interesting here, cheese was great, but they also included ranch mixed in with the cheese. You pre ranched my potatoes, bless you! It was a good base of ranch for the order, of course I got another side to go with the order. I really connected with this order of potato skins. Recommend eating these in house and not getting them to go, I’d say traveling with these might change the overall experience. I want to give a shout-out to the cute couple Dan & Kristen sitting next to us. Overheard them mentioning about the featuring the potato skin mobile, of course had to give them an official potato skin review business card. Like the Terminator, I’ll be back for more potato skins. Happy to give these a score of 4.7 out of 5 🥔.

07/21/2023

Was hoping to win the Powerball this week to go on the 2023 World Potato Skin Tour, but no luck! Bringing you a new review from located in Louisville, KY. Local sports bar with plenty of tvs and a nice size patio. This order comes in at $8.99 with 6 skins, not a bad RoP. The core toppings were included with this order, cheese, bacon and scallions. You’re not always going to find scallions these days, so always a plus. First bite, it’s greasy and not the best. The outside of the potato was almost like a casing, similar to biting into a smoked sausage or brat. Each one was like that and I’d have to attribute it to how greasy each one was. I need my crispy potato folks. The meat of the potato was soft in most spots but a little hard in the center. Get that fryer dialed in and these could be a top 5 potato skin in Louisville. Order does come with sour cream, got a side of ranch, nothing to write home about. This order comes in at 2.2 out of 5 🥔.

07/04/2023

Happy 4th of July!! We’ve got Party in the USA playing and happy to present a holiday review from I provided the best pen out there for reference of size for this order. Coming in at $10.69, not a good RoP for the size of the potatoes. These were dainty in size and would compare them to a one bite passed appetizer you would find at a wedding for Mr & Mrs Potatoskin. If you got two bites out of these, you were just being polite. There was no crisp to this order, not even the bacon. The meat of the potato was soft, but the outside soft and dry. Cheese was melted perfectly, but the bacon was low quality strips you would find on an all you can eat buffet. Think of this order of being fried first, then steaming them for a few minutes to make sure everything was warm and melted. The order comes with sour cream but got a side of ranch. That ranch was probably the best part of the review. needs to “Back it up Terry” because this review comes in at 1.7 out of 5 🥔.

Address

1820 Champions Club Ln
Henryville, IN
47126

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Potato skin reviews posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.