06/10/2026
Bon Appétit Magazine put 10 supermarket coffee ice creams to the test, and our Organic Coffee Ice Cream was named the decaf pick.
Made with organic ingredients, decaffeinated coffee, and Dutch-process cocoa, it’s the scoop for when you want coffee ice cream without the full espresso jolt.
Their take? Mild, pleasing, and “coffee enough, but not crazy coffee.”
Hot fudge optional, but highly recommended. Check out the full feature:
We tried 10 popular supermarket brands in the Test Kitchen.