09/24/2026
We start dogs slowly, on a long line, because when the going gets dodgy, dogs and humans revert to what they learned first. Maybe not ‘sexy’, but safer for handler, stock and dog.
It’s pretty exciting to see them develop into calm, thoughtful workers.
I don't think we're sending newcomers the right message about what makes a herding dog good. Some of what gets called "power" out there is really just a dog with no brakes and good PR.
Ask a group of handlers to define "power" sometime. Get comfortable, because that conversation is not wrapping up any time soon, and not everyone in it agrees on what they're even talking about. 😉
What we don't talk about nearly enough is softness and feel.
Livestock like to be treated the same way we do. I'll shuffle along just fine if you ask me nicely. Go watch how Disneyland moves ten thousand people through a park in a day. They've mastered the art of moving things along in a nice, quiet manner.
Now have someone bark orders at me, poke and prod, and I'm doing one of two things. Leaving (not really my style), or picking a fight. That's 50-something me talking. Do NOT push me, Karen. 😆 Apologies to the actual nice Karens out there. 🇨🇦
A dog who's polite but firm gets the work done in a way that looks almost boring. Boring should be the goal about 95% of the time. Boring dogs always seem to get the nice sets at trials. Boring dogs never seem to need their teeth, and somehow never get stood off either.
A lot of "powerful" dogs look impressive because they're constantly fighting with their stock. Ever wonder why? Probably because the stock feels threatened, same as I would be. It's hard to turn your back on something that's threatening you, whether you've got four legs or two.
So why all the talk about power, and so little about softness?
Because softness doesn't make for exciting photos. Video of sheep moving calmly across a field doesn't get shared. Nobody's leading an ad with "boring," and nobody's chasing likes and shares with a video of it either.
Here's where it actually backfires. If you're new to this and all you've heard is power good, weak bad, you might watch your dog chasing, slicing, barely stoppable, and call that powerful. It's not. It's slightly out of control with good camera angles. Livestock does not want to be moved by slightly out of control, no matter how good it looks on video.
My musings today after watching my boring dogs push boring sheep around a... gorgeous field. What are your thoughts? Are you "pro power and bite," or are you in the "move along ladies" camp?